| # | Name | Date | Host | City | Other |
| 1 | Allen, Ken | 3/02/2012 | Knights of Columbus | Cleveland, OH | Tournament Runner-up |
| 2 | Allen, Mark | 5/18/2012 | Riverside Golf Course | Mason, WV | Tournament Champ |
| 3 | Bobo, Tom | 5/18/2012 | Riverside Golf Course | Mason, WV | Tournament Champ |
| 4 | Bucci, Lanny | 1/29/2012 | Golf Dome | Girard, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 5 | Budnick, Phil | 1/29/2012 | Golf Dome | Girard, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 6 | Cahill, Jim | 3/11/2012 | Golf Dome | Girard, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 7 | Colonna, Wayne | 1/29/2012 | Golf Dome | Girard, OH | Tournament Runner-up |
| 8 | Corwin, Brandon | 4/01/2012 | Firehouse | Massillon, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 9 | Davis Jr, George | 1/29/2012 | Golf Dome | Girard, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 10 | Funk, Russ | 4/15/2012 | Gordy’s | Westerville, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 11 | Geho, Keith | 1/29/2012 | Golf Dome | Girard, OH | Tournament Runner-up |
| 12 | Groot, Linda | 2/12/2012 | KC’s Nashville Nights | Akron, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 13 | Hamedani, Hooman | 4/15/2012 | Gordy’s | Westerville, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 14 | Havasi, Bob | 3/21/2012 | Front Row | Brook Park, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 15 | Hennessey, Gary (Hoss) | 2/12/2012 | KC’s Nashville Nights | Akron, OH | Tournament Runner-up |
| 16 | Hissner, Adam | 2/12/2012 | KC’s Nashville Nights | Akron, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 17 | Jacques, Mike | 3/24/2012 | American Legion | Fremont, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 18 | Keller, Chuck | 3/02/2012 | Knights of Columbus | Cleveland, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 19 | Ledel, Jeff | 3/02/2012 | Knights of Columbus | Cleveland, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 20 | Lewis, Gary | 2/12/2012 | KC’s Nashville Nights | Akron, OH | Tournament Runner-up |
| 21 | Love, Chucky | 2/21/2012 | Front Row | Brook Park, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 22 | Lyons, Brett | 2/29/2012 | Around the Corner | Lakewood, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 23 | Mayberry, Chad | 4/15/2012 | Gordy’s | Westerville, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 24 | McBurney, Mitch | 4/01/2012 | Firehouse | Massillon, OH | Tournament Runner-up |
| 25 | McCafferty, Ryan | 1/24/2012 | Around the Corner | Lakewood, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 26 | Miller, Ron | 1/29/2012 | Golf Dome | Girard, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 27 | Myers, Brian | 3/02/2012 | Knights of Columbus | Cleveland, OH | Tournament Runner-up |
| 28 | Ngork, Bun | 4/15/2012 | Gordy’s | Westerville, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 29 | O’Heron, Jeff | 5/18/2012 | Knights of Columbus | Cleveland, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 30 | Petrie, TJ | 2/21/2012 | Front Row | Brook Park, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 31 | Pfaff, Mike | 5/18/2012 | Knights of Columbus | Cleveland, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 32 | Pugh, Stacia | 3/02/2012 | Knights of Columbus | Cleveland, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 33 | Reschke, David | 5/03/2012 | Around the Corner | Lakewood, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 34 | Reynolds, Jeff | 1/24/2012 | Around the Corner | Lakewood, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 35 | Shobe, Dale | 5/18/2012 | Riverside Golf Course | Mason, WV | Tournament Champ |
| 36 | Skotko, Alan | 2/29/2012 | Around the Corner | Lakewood, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 37 | Sobleskie Jr, Bill | 4/22/2012 | Fast Lane Bowling | Barberton, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 38 | Sobleskie Sr, Bill | 2/12/2012 | KC’s Nashville Nights | Akron, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 39 | Weiss, Ron | 3/21/2012 | Front Row | Brook Park, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 40 | Weitzel, Dave | 3/24/2012 | American Legion | Fremont, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 41 | Wendling, Steve | 4/22/2012 | Fast Lane Bowling | Barberton, OH | Tournament Champ |
| 42 | Wolf, Dan | 3/02/2012 | Knights of Columbus | Cleveland, OH | Tournament Runner-up |
| 43 | Yahnert, Dave | 4/04/2012 | Around the Corner | Lakewood, OH | Tournament Champ |
